#90 - Anime Review: Black Cat.
Dec. 31st, 2007 01:58 amTitle: Black Cat.
Original manga by: Kentaro Yabuki.
Studio: Gonzo.
Demographic: Shounen.
Genre: Action, adventure, fantasy, comedy.
Number of episodes: 24.
Story: Train Heartnet is a feared assassin for a secret organization known as Chronos. His marksmanship and dedication to his work is such that no one who has been targeted by the "Black Cat" has ever lived. All that changes, though, once Train meets a sweeper (freelance bounty hunter) named Saya Minatsuki, who unwittingly convinces him that he doesn't have to kill if he doesn't want to. In his quest to live by his own rules, like a stray cat, he meets another sweeper named Sven Vollfied, a former police officer; Eve, a young girl with formidable transformative abilities; and Rinslet Walker, a professional thief. Opposing Train and the Chronos Numbers is Creed Diskenth, a swordsman and former member of Chronos who hates how "soft" Train has become and detests that Chronos secretly controls, among other things, about one-third of the world's economy. With the help of the Apostles of the Stars, who all wield special powers as a result of the power of "Tao", Creed intends to re-make the world into his own paradise - hopefully with Train at his side.
Grade: B-.
I first got into Black Cat when a friend of mine recommended the manga to me on basis of a good story and great art. As of writing this review, I have currently read/collected up to volume 9 of the English volumes, and was not disappointed. Armed thusly, I dove into the anime series.
Those of you who are already familiar with the manga should be warned that the anime starts out on quite a different track. Whereas the manga shows Train already happily adapted to his job as a sweeper, working with Sven, the anime goes farther back to actually show Train as the cold-hearted Chronos Number XIII meeting with the carefree sweeper Saya Minatsuki. Considering that this is a 24-episode series, I think that this change, while certainly interesting, does a vast disservice to Train's character because within one episode we see him go from Silent McBroody to LOLBlackCat, with nothing but a "OKAY, SIX MONTHS HAVE JUST PASSED..." as explanation. It's an abrupt change that would likely jar a viewer who isn't familiar with Train from the manga. In addition, the way that Train meets Sven, Eve, and Rinslet is different: he's on one side (Chronos) and they're all on the other (Eve is Chronos' intended target, while Sven and Rinslet happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time). While they do all end up working together soon enough, to me there was always this distinct feeling that Train was always set apart from the group, not really belonging with them. Perhaps that's an intentional part of his character, but in the manga I at least was able to associate him with Sven, because the story started out with the two of them. Since the anime introduces Train to us as a loner, that fixes him in the audience's mind as such even if he does gain his little group (or big group) by the end of the series. I suppose it may be possible that Gonzo may have wanted to make Train distinct from Kenshin Himura, another former-assassin-turned-happy-go-lucky-rogue, by showing Train's roots, but if that's the case they needed at least 50-something episodes to make the change easier for the audience to swallow.
The other good guys are likeable enough, at least. Sven is a self-proclaimed gentleman who won't stand by if women are threatened, and wields an endless arsenal of weapons from an innocuous-looking briefcase; Eve, the token Lolicon Weapon of Mass Destruction, likes to read and to compete with Train for Sven's attention; Rinslet loves her work and won't back down from a challenge, and has no problems with using her feminine wiles to get what she needs. On the side of Chronos, the most memorable character from there is Chronos Number VII, Jenos Hazard, who is a flirt that eventually becomes Rinslet's love interest. (Personally I just like his weapon, Excelion, which is a series of metal threads that he can control to either slice through things or to wrap around things. No, it totally wouldn't work in real life, but it just looks cool. I'm also fond of Chronos Number X's hagoromo, woven through with threads of orihalcon metal.) Chronos Number I, Sephiria Arks, is also intriguing - her youthful face belies a frightening determination and conviction in the rightness of her work, and I always looked forward to seeing her kick ass. As for the other Numbers, well, you learn about them soon enough.
The Apostles of the Stars are a more amusing bunch. My personal favorite is Kyoko Kirisaki, the fire-breathing schoolgirl. I was quite disappointed when the anime cut out one of my favorite scenes from the manga, where Kyouko kisses a policeman and thusly incinerates him from the inside out. I could make a joke here about what a hot scene that was, but instead I'll just say: dude, come on. She's a schoolgirl. Who breathes fire. Close behind Kyoko is Charden Flamberg, who can form his blood into monsters and (I think?) weapons. He doesn't really get a lot of backstory, but you usually see him paired with Kyoko, and the two look cute together, so that's enough for me. Other members of the Apostles include Leon Elliot, a kid who hates adults and controls the air; Maro, a descendant of royalty from what is referred to as the "other continent" who controls gravity; Echidna Parass, a former actress who can create gates in space; Durham, who can wield his Tao powers in the form of infinite ammunition in his gun and doesn't get any backstory at all; and Shiki, another person from the "other continent" who control bugs. Yes, the Apostles are certainly an interesting bunch, wouldn't you say?
But oh, Creed. Creed Diskenth is in a league of his own. Creed is Dist the Rose (from Tales of the Abyss) if Dist ever got the cojones to lead the God-Generals and could swordfightwith an extendable chi sword of doom that totally isn't compensating for something else. They both even have light purple hair and the flower collars and the implication of Ultimate Gay and the creepy-ass fixation on their idols! Except that Dist's obsession with Jade can't even begin to compare with Creed's obsession with Train. No, I'm serious. If Dist's obsession with Jade is over nine thousand, then Creed's obsession with Train is over nine gazillion. [small spoilers ahead] Creed freakin' killed Saya because he thought that Saya was bewitching Train to "act against his nature" or whatever. And when Train finally gets to Creed's ultimate stronghold? Creed has a mural of Train (by his side, of course). And a statue. [/spoilers] Holy shit, dude, stop trying to get into Train's pants and start building fon machines or something.
Plot? What's that? Oh, right. There's three distinguishable story arcs in the series: Train starting to fall away from his role as a Chronos Number, Train trying to take down Creed without unwittingly becoming a pawn to Chronos, and something else that I'll talk about below the cut because it's very spoilery (and because I get a little ranty about it). I already talked about the story in terms of Train's character development, so I won't rehash that. The resolution of the conflict between Train's group, Chronos, and the Apostles is epic enough, although I will say that Leon vs. Eve had to be one of the most badass fights in the series, if not the most badass. It probably says something that I thought a showdown between two (admittedly superpowered) kids was more interesting and epic than a fight between a gunman and a swordsman, but I'm not sure what.
Animation and art was pretty good, although the opening sequence gave me headaches. (I can't remember the ending sequence because I never watched it - I always just skipped to the next episode.) The soundtrack had some nice moments, but ultimately didn't strike my fancy, and I didn't care for the opening or (what I could remember of the) ending, either. Still, execution of all the main elements was solid, which is why Black Cat gets a B as a base grade. The reason it got docked to a B- is explained in more detail below the cut. It may be an unfair reason for lowering the grade, but it annoyed me so much that I had to account for it somehow.
( I've come to bring the rantiness )
Random thought: Train's Hades gun looks like a revolver, so how the hell is he able to keep up a near-constant round of fire? I'm not complaining, mind you, because he looks cool while doing it, but the question should at least be out there.
-Reileen
she's a dwelling place for demons
Original manga by: Kentaro Yabuki.
Studio: Gonzo.
Demographic: Shounen.
Genre: Action, adventure, fantasy, comedy.
Number of episodes: 24.
Story: Train Heartnet is a feared assassin for a secret organization known as Chronos. His marksmanship and dedication to his work is such that no one who has been targeted by the "Black Cat" has ever lived. All that changes, though, once Train meets a sweeper (freelance bounty hunter) named Saya Minatsuki, who unwittingly convinces him that he doesn't have to kill if he doesn't want to. In his quest to live by his own rules, like a stray cat, he meets another sweeper named Sven Vollfied, a former police officer; Eve, a young girl with formidable transformative abilities; and Rinslet Walker, a professional thief. Opposing Train and the Chronos Numbers is Creed Diskenth, a swordsman and former member of Chronos who hates how "soft" Train has become and detests that Chronos secretly controls, among other things, about one-third of the world's economy. With the help of the Apostles of the Stars, who all wield special powers as a result of the power of "Tao", Creed intends to re-make the world into his own paradise - hopefully with Train at his side.
Grade: B-.
I first got into Black Cat when a friend of mine recommended the manga to me on basis of a good story and great art. As of writing this review, I have currently read/collected up to volume 9 of the English volumes, and was not disappointed. Armed thusly, I dove into the anime series.
Those of you who are already familiar with the manga should be warned that the anime starts out on quite a different track. Whereas the manga shows Train already happily adapted to his job as a sweeper, working with Sven, the anime goes farther back to actually show Train as the cold-hearted Chronos Number XIII meeting with the carefree sweeper Saya Minatsuki. Considering that this is a 24-episode series, I think that this change, while certainly interesting, does a vast disservice to Train's character because within one episode we see him go from Silent McBroody to LOLBlackCat, with nothing but a "OKAY, SIX MONTHS HAVE JUST PASSED..." as explanation. It's an abrupt change that would likely jar a viewer who isn't familiar with Train from the manga. In addition, the way that Train meets Sven, Eve, and Rinslet is different: he's on one side (Chronos) and they're all on the other (Eve is Chronos' intended target, while Sven and Rinslet happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong time). While they do all end up working together soon enough, to me there was always this distinct feeling that Train was always set apart from the group, not really belonging with them. Perhaps that's an intentional part of his character, but in the manga I at least was able to associate him with Sven, because the story started out with the two of them. Since the anime introduces Train to us as a loner, that fixes him in the audience's mind as such even if he does gain his little group (or big group) by the end of the series. I suppose it may be possible that Gonzo may have wanted to make Train distinct from Kenshin Himura, another former-assassin-turned-happy-go-lucky-rogue, by showing Train's roots, but if that's the case they needed at least 50-something episodes to make the change easier for the audience to swallow.
The other good guys are likeable enough, at least. Sven is a self-proclaimed gentleman who won't stand by if women are threatened, and wields an endless arsenal of weapons from an innocuous-looking briefcase; Eve, the token Lolicon Weapon of Mass Destruction, likes to read and to compete with Train for Sven's attention; Rinslet loves her work and won't back down from a challenge, and has no problems with using her feminine wiles to get what she needs. On the side of Chronos, the most memorable character from there is Chronos Number VII, Jenos Hazard, who is a flirt that eventually becomes Rinslet's love interest. (Personally I just like his weapon, Excelion, which is a series of metal threads that he can control to either slice through things or to wrap around things. No, it totally wouldn't work in real life, but it just looks cool. I'm also fond of Chronos Number X's hagoromo, woven through with threads of orihalcon metal.) Chronos Number I, Sephiria Arks, is also intriguing - her youthful face belies a frightening determination and conviction in the rightness of her work, and I always looked forward to seeing her kick ass. As for the other Numbers, well, you learn about them soon enough.
The Apostles of the Stars are a more amusing bunch. My personal favorite is Kyoko Kirisaki, the fire-breathing schoolgirl. I was quite disappointed when the anime cut out one of my favorite scenes from the manga, where Kyouko kisses a policeman and thusly incinerates him from the inside out. I could make a joke here about what a hot scene that was, but instead I'll just say: dude, come on. She's a schoolgirl. Who breathes fire. Close behind Kyoko is Charden Flamberg, who can form his blood into monsters and (I think?) weapons. He doesn't really get a lot of backstory, but you usually see him paired with Kyoko, and the two look cute together, so that's enough for me. Other members of the Apostles include Leon Elliot, a kid who hates adults and controls the air; Maro, a descendant of royalty from what is referred to as the "other continent" who controls gravity; Echidna Parass, a former actress who can create gates in space; Durham, who can wield his Tao powers in the form of infinite ammunition in his gun and doesn't get any backstory at all; and Shiki, another person from the "other continent" who control bugs. Yes, the Apostles are certainly an interesting bunch, wouldn't you say?
But oh, Creed. Creed Diskenth is in a league of his own. Creed is Dist the Rose (from Tales of the Abyss) if Dist ever got the cojones to lead the God-Generals and could swordfight
Plot? What's that? Oh, right. There's three distinguishable story arcs in the series: Train starting to fall away from his role as a Chronos Number, Train trying to take down Creed without unwittingly becoming a pawn to Chronos, and something else that I'll talk about below the cut because it's very spoilery (and because I get a little ranty about it). I already talked about the story in terms of Train's character development, so I won't rehash that. The resolution of the conflict between Train's group, Chronos, and the Apostles is epic enough, although I will say that Leon vs. Eve had to be one of the most badass fights in the series, if not the most badass. It probably says something that I thought a showdown between two (admittedly superpowered) kids was more interesting and epic than a fight between a gunman and a swordsman, but I'm not sure what.
Animation and art was pretty good, although the opening sequence gave me headaches. (I can't remember the ending sequence because I never watched it - I always just skipped to the next episode.) The soundtrack had some nice moments, but ultimately didn't strike my fancy, and I didn't care for the opening or (what I could remember of the) ending, either. Still, execution of all the main elements was solid, which is why Black Cat gets a B as a base grade. The reason it got docked to a B- is explained in more detail below the cut. It may be an unfair reason for lowering the grade, but it annoyed me so much that I had to account for it somehow.
( I've come to bring the rantiness )
Random thought: Train's Hades gun looks like a revolver, so how the hell is he able to keep up a near-constant round of fire? I'm not complaining, mind you, because he looks cool while doing it, but the question should at least be out there.
-Reileen
she's a dwelling place for demons